	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	5.77
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	108.	0.586	5.77	107.	-3.89	0.401	0.666	0.533
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	89.8	1.60	5.77	87.7	-3.10	0.466	0.585	0.525
CLM-Princeton	[-]	139.	2.61	5.77	135.	-2.35	0.532	0.510	0.521
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	56.7	0.599	5.77	56.8	-3.75	0.408	0.582	0.495
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	50.8	0.759	5.77	50.7	-3.60	0.409	0.468	0.438
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	76.6	0.915	5.77	76.7	-3.46	0.415	0.386	0.401
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	24.6	0.535	5.77	24.2	-3.94	0.401	0.685	0.543
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	36.9	1.21	5.77	35.5	-3.42	0.438	0.633	0.536
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	47.3	1.41	5.77	46.7	-3.29	0.447	0.526	0.487
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	62.2	0.565	5.77	63.4	-3.91	0.404	0.651	0.527
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	57.7	1.18	5.77	58.4	-3.45	0.454	0.786	0.620
Mean-Princeton	[-]	86.0	1.58	5.77	87.0	-3.15	0.483	0.735	0.609

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

5.77

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

108.

0.586

5.77

107.

-3.89

0.401

0.666

0.533

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

89.8

1.60

5.77

87.7

-3.10

0.466

0.585

0.525

CLM-Princeton

[-]

139.

2.61

5.77

135.

-2.35

0.532

0.510

0.521

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

56.7

0.599

5.77

56.8

-3.75

0.408

0.582

0.495

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

50.8

0.759

5.77

50.7

-3.60

0.409

0.468

0.438

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

76.6

0.915

5.77

76.7

-3.46

0.415

0.386

0.401

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

24.6

0.535

5.77

24.2

-3.94

0.401

0.685

0.543

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

36.9

1.21

5.77

35.5

-3.42

0.438

0.633

0.536

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

47.3

1.41

5.77

46.7

-3.29

0.447

0.526

0.487

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

62.2

0.565

5.77

63.4

-3.91

0.404

0.651

0.527

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

57.7

1.18

5.77

58.4

-3.45

0.454

0.786

0.620

Mean-Princeton

[-]

86.0

1.58

5.77

87.0

-3.15

0.483

0.735

0.609

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	349.
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	720.	441.	347.	274.	2.11	1.31	0.579	0.758	0.669
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	577.	352.	347.	219.	2.11	0.0359	0.639	0.856	0.747
CLM-Princeton	[-]	811.	469.	347.	339.	2.11	1.71	0.568	0.731	0.649
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	739.	485.	349.	247.	0.294	1.92	0.625	0.800	0.713
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	663.	429.	349.	228.	0.294	1.13	0.673	0.863	0.768
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	850.	527.	349.	315.	0.294	2.51	0.603	0.768	0.686
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	354.	288.	319.	64.4	30.2	-0.488	0.633	0.896	0.765
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	387.	277.	319.	109.	30.2	-0.657	0.651	0.906	0.778
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	452.	320.	319.	130.	30.2	0.0298	0.645	0.895	0.770
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	672.	435.	349.	237.	0.334	1.21	0.652	0.846	0.749
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	604.	380.	349.	224.	0.334	0.443	0.699	0.910	0.805
Mean-Princeton	[-]	780.	472.	349.	308.	0.334	1.74	0.641	0.831	0.736

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

349.

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

720.

441.

347.

274.

2.11

1.31

0.579

0.758

0.669

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

577.

352.

347.

219.

2.11

0.0359

0.639

0.856

0.747

CLM-Princeton

[-]

811.

469.

347.

339.

2.11

1.71

0.568

0.731

0.649

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

739.

485.

349.

247.

0.294

1.92

0.625

0.800

0.713

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

663.

429.

349.

228.

0.294

1.13

0.673

0.863

0.768

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

850.

527.

349.

315.

0.294

2.51

0.603

0.768

0.686

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

354.

288.

319.

64.4

30.2

-0.488

0.633

0.896

0.765

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

387.

277.

319.

109.

30.2

-0.657

0.651

0.906

0.778

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

452.

320.

319.

130.

30.2

0.0298

0.645

0.895

0.770

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

672.

435.

349.

237.

0.334

1.21

0.652

0.846

0.749

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

604.

380.

349.

224.

0.334

0.443

0.699

0.910

0.805

Mean-Princeton

[-]

780.

472.

349.

308.

0.334

1.74

0.641

0.831

0.736

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	20.1
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	7.31	5.15	20.0	1.59	0.0870	-0.923	0.452	0.345	0.398
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	5.04	3.55	20.0	1.22	0.0870	-1.02	0.423	0.197	0.310
CLM-Princeton	[-]	6.54	4.47	20.0	1.46	0.0870	-0.965	0.441	0.373	0.407
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	9.97	7.33	20.1	2.48	0.0246	-0.769	0.456	0.684	0.570
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	9.19	6.71	20.1	2.36	0.0246	-0.807	0.456	0.680	0.568
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	11.9	8.80	20.1	2.84	0.0246	-0.677	0.461	0.686	0.574
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	9.90	9.10	19.4	0.782	0.702	-0.678	0.532	0.698	0.615
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	12.0	10.9	19.4	1.20	0.702	-0.557	0.569	0.806	0.688
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	8.94	8.25	19.4	0.555	0.702	-0.735	0.508	0.699	0.603
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	10.5	7.84	20.1	2.45	0.0132	-0.755	0.489	0.683	0.586
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	10.1	7.63	20.1	2.24	0.0132	-0.768	0.502	0.638	0.570
Mean-Princeton	[-]	10.9	7.95	20.1	2.62	0.0132	-0.748	0.486	0.701	0.593

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

20.1

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

7.31

5.15

20.0

1.59

0.0870

-0.923

0.452

0.345

0.398

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

5.04

3.55

20.0

1.22

0.0870

-1.02

0.423

0.197

0.310

CLM-Princeton

[-]

6.54

4.47

20.0

1.46

0.0870

-0.965

0.441

0.373

0.407

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

9.97

7.33

20.1

2.48

0.0246

-0.769

0.456

0.684

0.570

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

9.19

6.71

20.1

2.36

0.0246

-0.807

0.456

0.680

0.568

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

11.9

8.80

20.1

2.84

0.0246

-0.677

0.461

0.686

0.574

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

9.90

9.10

19.4

0.782

0.702

-0.678

0.532

0.698

0.615

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

12.0

10.9

19.4

1.20

0.702

-0.557

0.569

0.806

0.688

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

8.94

8.25

19.4

0.555

0.702

-0.735

0.508

0.699

0.603

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

10.5

7.84

20.1

2.45

0.0132

-0.755

0.489

0.683

0.586

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

10.1

7.63

20.1

2.24

0.0132

-0.768

0.502

0.638

0.570

Mean-Princeton

[-]

10.9

7.95

20.1

2.62

0.0132

-0.748

0.486

0.701

0.593

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	5.36
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	2.73	0.963	5.36	1.78	0.00265	-1.74	0.434	0.364	0.399
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	2.46	0.974	5.36	1.42	0.00265	-1.73	0.432	0.491	0.461
CLM-Princeton	[-]	3.00	1.05	5.36	2.02	0.00265	-1.71	0.441	0.451	0.446
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	2.95	0.475	5.36	1.94	0.000270	-1.93	0.389	0.354	0.372
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	3.18	0.649	5.36	1.91	0.000270	-1.86	0.393	0.492	0.442
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	3.56	0.628	5.36	2.28	0.000270	-1.87	0.394	0.463	0.429
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	0.916	0.346	5.33	0.589	0.0353	-1.99	0.391	0.0972	0.244
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	3.64	1.16	5.33	2.41	0.0353	-1.67	0.427	0.433	0.430
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	1.91	0.557	5.33	1.38	0.0353	-1.90	0.405	0.214	0.309
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	1.95	0.562	5.36	1.55	0.000270	-1.87	0.403	0.148	0.275
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	2.89	0.887	5.36	2.02	0.000270	-1.74	0.425	0.327	0.376
Mean-Princeton	[-]	2.72	0.717	5.36	2.05	0.000270	-1.81	0.412	0.261	0.337

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

5.36

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

2.73

0.963

5.36

1.78

0.00265

-1.74

0.434

0.364

0.399

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

2.46

0.974

5.36

1.42

0.00265

-1.73

0.432

0.491

0.461

CLM-Princeton

[-]

3.00

1.05

5.36

2.02

0.00265

-1.71

0.441

0.451

0.446

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

2.95

0.475

5.36

1.94

0.000270

-1.93

0.389

0.354

0.372

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

3.18

0.649

5.36

1.91

0.000270

-1.86

0.393

0.492

0.442

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

3.56

0.628

5.36

2.28

0.000270

-1.87

0.394

0.463

0.429

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

0.916

0.346

5.33

0.589

0.0353

-1.99

0.391

0.0972

0.244

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

3.64

1.16

5.33

2.41

0.0353

-1.67

0.427

0.433

0.430

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

1.91

0.557

5.33

1.38

0.0353

-1.90

0.405

0.214

0.309

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

1.95

0.562

5.36

1.55

0.000270

-1.87

0.403

0.148

0.275

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

2.89

0.887

5.36

2.02

0.000270

-1.74

0.425

0.327

0.376

Mean-Princeton

[-]

2.72

0.717

5.36

2.05

0.000270

-1.81

0.412

0.261

0.337

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	2.08
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	7.61	2.69	2.05	4.41	0.0228	2.21	0.608	0.888	0.748
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	7.08	2.69	2.05	3.87	0.0228	2.40	0.622	0.879	0.750
CLM-Princeton	[-]	8.84	3.24	2.05	4.97	0.0228	4.50	0.587	0.909	0.748
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	5.31	2.99	2.08	1.85		4.08	0.666	0.828	0.747
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	5.29	2.86	2.08	1.75		3.55	0.696	0.871	0.784
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	6.66	3.37	2.08	2.41		5.38	0.698	0.831	0.765
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	3.10	1.46	1.80	1.55	0.281	-1.50	0.568	0.704	0.636
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	2.72	1.29	1.80	1.37	0.281	-2.36	0.564	0.539	0.552
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	4.49	1.70	1.80	2.06	0.281	-0.508	0.606	0.695	0.651
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	6.90	2.71	2.08	2.99		2.30	0.620	0.837	0.729
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	6.46	2.62	2.08	2.71		1.97	0.638	0.798	0.718
Mean-Princeton	[-]	8.27	3.20	2.08	3.63		4.08	0.651	0.869	0.760

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

2.08

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

7.61

2.69

2.05

4.41

0.0228

2.21

0.608

0.888

0.748

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

7.08

2.69

2.05

3.87

0.0228

2.40

0.622

0.879

0.750

CLM-Princeton

[-]

8.84

3.24

2.05

4.97

0.0228

4.50

0.587

0.909

0.748

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

5.31

2.99

2.08

1.85

4.08

0.666

0.828

0.747

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

5.29

2.86

2.08

1.75

3.55

0.696

0.871

0.784

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

6.66

3.37

2.08

2.41

5.38

0.698

0.831

0.765

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

3.10

1.46

1.80

1.55

0.281

-1.50

0.568

0.704

0.636

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

2.72

1.29

1.80

1.37

0.281

-2.36

0.564

0.539

0.552

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

4.49

1.70

1.80

2.06

0.281

-0.508

0.606

0.695

0.651

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

6.90

2.71

2.08

2.99

2.30

0.620

0.837

0.729

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

6.46

2.62

2.08

2.71

1.97

0.638

0.798

0.718

Mean-Princeton

[-]

8.27

3.20

2.08

3.63

4.08

0.651

0.869

0.760

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	25.4
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	106.	28.8	25.2	77.7	0.196	0.883	0.588	0.774	0.681
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	88.1	27.4	25.2	60.3	0.196	0.487	0.639	0.848	0.744
CLM-Princeton	[-]	127.	36.8	25.2	89.2	0.196	2.75	0.623	0.817	0.720
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	121.	42.2	25.4	77.0	0.00194	3.98	0.547	0.708	0.627
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	112.	39.8	25.4	70.6	0.00194	3.38	0.606	0.786	0.696
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	158.	52.2	25.4	103.	0.00194	6.28	0.490	0.618	0.554
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	40.4	21.1	23.3	18.1	2.07	-0.604	0.593	0.847	0.720
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	63.5	26.4	23.3	35.6	2.07	0.824	0.601	0.861	0.731
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	77.4	33.6	23.3	41.5	2.07	2.73	0.565	0.852	0.709
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	95.6	33.9	25.4	61.9		1.98	0.605	0.843	0.724
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	93.5	33.9	25.4	59.5		1.99	0.651	0.900	0.775
Mean-Princeton	[-]	128.	44.4	25.4	83.1		4.44	0.568	0.846	0.707

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

25.4

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

106.

28.8

25.2

77.7

0.196

0.883

0.588

0.774

0.681

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

88.1

27.4

25.2

60.3

0.196

0.487

0.639

0.848

0.744

CLM-Princeton

[-]

127.

36.8

25.2

89.2

0.196

2.75

0.623

0.817

0.720

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

121.

42.2

25.4

77.0

0.00194

3.98

0.547

0.708

0.627

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

112.

39.8

25.4

70.6

0.00194

3.38

0.606

0.786

0.696

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

158.

52.2

25.4

103.

0.00194

6.28

0.490

0.618

0.554

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

40.4

21.1

23.3

18.1

2.07

-0.604

0.593

0.847

0.720

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

63.5

26.4

23.3

35.6

2.07

0.824

0.601

0.861

0.731

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

77.4

33.6

23.3

41.5

2.07

2.73

0.565

0.852

0.709

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

95.6

33.9

25.4

61.9

1.98

0.605

0.843

0.724

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

93.5

33.9

25.4

59.5

1.99

0.651

0.900

0.775

Mean-Princeton

[-]

128.

44.4

25.4

83.1

4.44

0.568

0.846

0.707

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	60.5
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	98.6	97.6	59.9	0.0685	0.683	8.01	0.588	0.891	0.740
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	84.5	83.9	59.9	0.0701	0.683	5.09	0.681	0.945	0.813
CLM-Princeton	[-]	103.	102.	59.9	0.0730	0.683	8.97	0.553	0.865	0.709
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	90.0	86.5	60.5	2.55	0.0633	5.31	0.674	0.946	0.810
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	80.1	76.9	60.5	2.46	0.0633	3.36	0.743	0.955	0.849
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	88.3	84.6	60.5	2.70	0.0633	4.94	0.688	0.947	0.818
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	60.1	57.1	51.0	0.0129	9.59	1.63	0.714	0.876	0.795
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	47.1	44.9	51.0	0.0117	9.59	-1.55	0.780	0.958	0.869
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	55.1	52.4	51.0	0.0142	9.59	0.412	0.750	0.922	0.836
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	88.1	88.2	60.5	2.52	0.0267	5.61	0.669	0.949	0.809
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	76.1	75.7	60.5	2.44	0.0267	3.08	0.756	0.959	0.857
Mean-Princeton	[-]	88.4	88.1	60.5	2.70	0.0267	5.60	0.670	0.948	0.809

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

60.5

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

98.6

97.6

59.9

0.0685

0.683

8.01

0.588

0.891

0.740

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

84.5

83.9

59.9

0.0701

0.683

5.09

0.681

0.945

0.813

CLM-Princeton

[-]

103.

102.

59.9

0.0730

0.683

8.97

0.553

0.865

0.709

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

90.0

86.5

60.5

2.55

0.0633

5.31

0.674

0.946

0.810

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

80.1

76.9

60.5

2.46

0.0633

3.36

0.743

0.955

0.849

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

88.3

84.6

60.5

2.70

0.0633

4.94

0.688

0.947

0.818

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

60.1

57.1

51.0

0.0129

9.59

1.63

0.714

0.876

0.795

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

47.1

44.9

51.0

0.0117

9.59

-1.55

0.780

0.958

0.869

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

55.1

52.4

51.0

0.0142

9.59

0.412

0.750

0.922

0.836

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

88.1

88.2

60.5

2.52

0.0267

5.61

0.669

0.949

0.809

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

76.1

75.7

60.5

2.44

0.0267

3.08

0.756

0.959

0.857

Mean-Princeton

[-]

88.4

88.1

60.5

2.70

0.0267

5.60

0.670

0.948

0.809

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	214.
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	295.	291.	212.	1.54	2.57	2.23	0.601	0.795	0.698
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	219.	216.	212.	1.39	2.57	0.0890	0.665	0.885	0.775
CLM-Princeton	[-]	305.	301.	212.	1.70	2.57	2.52	0.582	0.763	0.672
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	330.	328.	214.	4.45	0.292	3.19	0.652	0.865	0.759
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	285.	284.	214.	4.10	0.292	1.93	0.703	0.909	0.806
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	357.	355.	214.	4.86	0.292	3.93	0.621	0.844	0.732
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	188.	190.	195.	0.244	19.3	-0.165	0.652	0.911	0.782
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	176.	176.	195.	0.236	19.3	-0.588	0.656	0.893	0.775
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	207.	209.	195.	0.285	19.3	0.462	0.665	0.915	0.790
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	301.	291.	214.	4.12	0.408	2.15	0.683	0.898	0.791
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	253.	245.	214.	3.80	0.408	0.863	0.726	0.933	0.830
Mean-Princeton	[-]	322.	312.	214.	4.47	0.408	2.73	0.667	0.888	0.778

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

214.

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

295.

291.

212.

1.54

2.57

2.23

0.601

0.795

0.698

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

219.

216.

212.

1.39

2.57

0.0890

0.665

0.885

0.775

CLM-Princeton

[-]

305.

301.

212.

1.70

2.57

2.52

0.582

0.763

0.672

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

330.

328.

214.

4.45

0.292

3.19

0.652

0.865

0.759

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

285.

284.

214.

4.10

0.292

1.93

0.703

0.909

0.806

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

357.

355.

214.

4.86

0.292

3.93

0.621

0.844

0.732

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

188.

190.

195.

0.244

19.3

-0.165

0.652

0.911

0.782

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

176.

195.

0.236

19.3

-0.588

0.656

0.893

0.775

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

207.

209.

195.

0.285

19.3

0.462

0.665

0.915

0.790

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

301.

291.

214.

4.12

0.408

2.15

0.683

0.898

0.791

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

253.

245.

214.

3.80

0.408

0.863

0.726

0.933

0.830

Mean-Princeton

[-]

322.

312.

214.

4.47

0.408

2.73

0.667

0.888

0.778

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	0.801
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	26.9	0.0204	0.801	30.4	-3.82	0.379	0.170	0.274
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	18.1	0.108	0.801	19.6	-3.39	0.417	0.763	0.590
CLM-Princeton	[-]	43.5	0.124	0.801	48.2	-3.30	0.427	0.790	0.608
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	15.5	0.0103	0.801	15.9	-3.83	0.373	0.577	0.475
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	13.9	0.0147	0.801	14.2	-3.79	0.374	0.557	0.465
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	21.1	0.0149	0.801	21.6	-3.79	0.374	0.538	0.456
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	7.89	0.00290	0.801	7.94	-3.96	0.369	0.0117	0.190
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	12.1	0.0127	0.801	12.1	-3.92	0.374	0.103	0.238
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	19.2	0.00997	0.801	18.8	-3.93	0.373	0.0778	0.225
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	17.6	0.0111	0.801	18.4	-3.89	0.373	0.0245	0.199
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	14.8	0.0425	0.801	15.5	-3.74	0.388	0.102	0.245
Mean-Princeton	[-]	28.9	0.0490	0.801	30.0	-3.70	0.391	0.137	0.264

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

0.801

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

26.9

0.0204

0.801

30.4

-3.82

0.379

0.170

0.274

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

18.1

0.108

0.801

19.6

-3.39

0.417

0.763

0.590

CLM-Princeton

[-]

43.5

0.124

0.801

48.2

-3.30

0.427

0.790

0.608

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

15.5

0.0103

0.801

15.9

-3.83

0.373

0.577

0.475

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

13.9

0.0147

0.801

14.2

-3.79

0.374

0.557

0.465

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

21.1

0.0149

0.801

21.6

-3.79

0.374

0.538

0.456

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

7.89

0.00290

0.801

7.94

-3.96

0.369

0.0117

0.190

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

12.1

0.0127

0.801

12.1

-3.92

0.374

0.103

0.238

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

19.2

0.00997

0.801

18.8

-3.93

0.373

0.0778

0.225

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

17.6

0.0111

0.801

18.4

-3.89

0.373

0.0245

0.199

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

14.8

0.0425

0.801

15.5

-3.74

0.388

0.102

0.245

Mean-Princeton

[-]

28.9

0.0490

0.801

30.0

-3.70

0.391

0.137

0.264

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]	Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]	Bias [kg m-2]	Bias Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	16.7
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	25.2	9.16	16.7	16.0	0.0266	-1.38	0.530	0.786	0.658
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	23.5	10.4	16.7	12.7	0.0266	-1.17	0.545	0.763	0.654
CLM-Princeton	[-]	34.2	12.6	16.7	21.3	0.0266	-0.758	0.561	0.718	0.639
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	42.9	17.6	16.7	25.4	0.000419	0.156	0.536	0.632	0.584
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	43.3	18.3	16.7	24.6	0.000419	0.281	0.546	0.638	0.592
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	57.4	22.9	16.7	34.2	0.000419	1.12	0.491	0.497	0.494
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	11.7	6.74	16.3	4.48	0.353	-1.83	0.513	0.807	0.660
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	27.8	12.8	16.3	13.8	0.353	-0.676	0.518	0.755	0.636
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	24.3	11.9	16.3	11.4	0.353	-0.847	0.536	0.727	0.632
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	29.7	11.6	16.7	17.7		-0.931	0.588	0.846	0.717
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	34.2	14.4	16.7	19.3		-0.426	0.595	0.823	0.709
Mean-Princeton	[-]	42.1	16.4	16.7	25.1		-0.0484	0.588	0.735	0.662

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [Pg]

Model Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [Pg]

Bias [kg m-2]

Bias Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

16.7

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

25.2

9.16

16.7

16.0

0.0266

-1.38

0.530

0.786

0.658

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

23.5

10.4

16.7

12.7

0.0266

-1.17

0.545

0.763

0.654

CLM-Princeton

[-]

34.2

12.6

16.7

21.3

0.0266

-0.758

0.561

0.718

0.639

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

42.9

17.6

16.7

25.4

0.000419

0.156

0.536

0.632

0.584

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

43.3

18.3

16.7

24.6

0.000419

0.281

0.546

0.638

0.592

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

57.4

22.9

16.7

34.2

0.000419

1.12

0.491

0.497

0.494

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

11.7

6.74

16.3

4.48

0.353

-1.83

0.513

0.807

0.660

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

27.8

12.8

16.3

13.8

0.353

-0.676

0.518

0.755

0.636

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

24.3

11.9

16.3

11.4

0.353

-0.847

0.536

0.727

0.632

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

29.7

11.6

16.7

17.7

-0.931

0.588

0.846

0.717

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

34.2

14.4

16.7

19.3

-0.426

0.595

0.823

0.709

Mean-Princeton

[-]

42.1

16.4

16.7

25.1

-0.0484

0.588

0.735

0.662

Temporally integrated period mean click to collapse contents

BENCHMARK MEAN Data not available

MODEL MEAN Data not available

BIAS

BIAS SCORE Data not available

SPATIAL TAYLOR DIAGRAM Data not available

MODEL COLORS Data not available

Data Information

Mean State
All Models
Data Information

Title:: Global Tropical Forest Biomass

Institution:: NASA-JPL (NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California 91109, USA)

Source:: 4079 in situ inventory plots, satellite light detection and ranging (LiDAR) samples of forest structure, and optical and microwave imagery (1-km resolution) to extrapolate estimates

History:: 2015-01-08-T06:37:41Z Converted from 1 km x 1 km to 0.5 degree x 0.5 degree by Mingquan Mu (mmu@uci.edu) on Fri Jan 9 10:37:41 PST 2015

References:: Saatchi, S. S., N. L. Harris, S. Brown, M. Lefsky, E. T. A. Mitchard, W. Salas, B. R. Zutta, W. Buermann, S. L. Lewis, S. Hagen, S. Petrova, L. White, M. Silman, and A. Morel (2011), Benchmark map of forest carbon stocks in tropical regions across three continents, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., 108(24):9899-9904, doi:10.1073/pnas.1019576108.

Conventions:: CF-1.6

Institute_id:: NASA-JPL

Creation_date:: 2015-01-08-T06:37:41Z

Product:: observations

Data_structure:: grid

Realm:: land

Contact:: Prof. James T. Randerson (jranders@uci.edu) or Dr. Mingquan Mu (mmu@uci.edu)

Biomass / Tropical / 1995-2006 / global / ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

Temporally integrated period mean click to collapse contents

Spatially integrated regional mean click to collapse contents

Biomass / Tropical / 1995-2006 / global / MNAME

Data Information

loading