	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	53.3
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	52.7	52.6	53.4	45.9	-0.735	18.8	0.272	0.858	0.772	0.981	0.983	0.873
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	49.8	49.7	53.4	45.9	-3.69	16.2	0.166	0.884	0.789	0.988	0.987	0.887
CLM-Princeton	[-]	48.9	48.9	53.6	46.0	-4.76	16.9	0.145	0.864	0.787	0.990	0.946	0.875
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	55.2	55.2	53.4	38.5	2.02	19.4	0.237	0.844	0.772	0.984	0.984	0.871
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	54.5	54.6	53.4	38.5	1.32	16.5	0.196	0.896	0.782	0.986	0.986	0.886
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	52.8	52.9	53.5	38.7	-0.481	16.8	0.148	0.886	0.780	0.990	0.963	0.880
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	64.7	64.4	53.9	42.6	1.99	19.2	0.224	0.843	0.773	0.984	0.975	0.869
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	54.5	55.5	53.9	42.6	1.55	16.7	0.167	0.893	0.779	0.988	0.989	0.886
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	57.0	56.9	53.9	42.6	1.95	18.5	0.173	0.871	0.764	0.988	0.933	0.864
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	55.3	55.9	53.9	42.6	1.99	19.2	0.224	0.843	0.773	0.984	0.975	0.869
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	54.5	55.5	53.9	42.6	1.55	16.7	0.167	0.893	0.779	0.988	0.989	0.886
Mean-Princeton	[-]	55.1	55.9	53.9	42.6	1.95	18.5	0.173	0.871	0.764	0.988	0.933	0.864

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

53.3

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

52.7

52.6

53.4

45.9

-0.735

18.8

0.272

0.858

0.772

0.981

0.983

0.873

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

49.8

49.7

53.4

45.9

-3.69

16.2

0.166

0.884

0.789

0.988

0.987

0.887

CLM-Princeton

[-]

48.9

53.6

46.0

-4.76

16.9

0.145

0.864

0.787

0.990

0.946

0.875

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

55.2

53.4

38.5

2.02

19.4

0.237

0.844

0.772

0.984

0.871

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

54.5

54.6

53.4

38.5

1.32

16.5

0.196

0.896

0.782

0.986

0.886

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

52.8

52.9

53.5

38.7

-0.481

16.8

0.148

0.886

0.780

0.990

0.963

0.880

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

64.7

64.4

53.9

42.6

1.99

19.2

0.224

0.843

0.773

0.984

0.975

0.869

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

54.5

55.5

53.9

42.6

1.55

16.7

0.167

0.893

0.779

0.988

0.989

0.886

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

57.0

56.9

53.9

42.6

1.95

18.5

0.173

0.871

0.764

0.988

0.933

0.864

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

55.3

55.9

53.9

42.6

1.99

19.2

0.224

0.843

0.773

0.984

0.975

0.869

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

54.5

55.5

53.9

42.6

1.55

16.7

0.167

0.893

0.779

0.988

0.989

0.886

Mean-Princeton

[-]

55.1

55.9

53.9

42.6

1.95

18.5

0.173

0.871

0.764

0.988

0.933

0.864

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	91.0
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	85.5	80.9	89.2	124.	-8.34	21.6	0.826	0.688	0.645	0.901	0.983	0.772
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	80.9	76.0	89.2	124.	-13.2	22.1	0.666	0.646	0.665	0.920	0.969	0.773
CLM-Princeton	[-]	78.2	74.4	89.2	124.	-14.7	23.4	0.618	0.615	0.678	0.927	0.919	0.764
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	89.0	88.8	90.2	134.	-1.31	20.9	0.839	0.708	0.650	0.901	0.984	0.779
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	86.2	86.0	90.2	134.	-4.09	19.3	0.643	0.723	0.665	0.925	0.979	0.792
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	83.9	83.7	90.2	134.	-6.37	20.1	0.638	0.699	0.673	0.925	0.945	0.783
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	94.8	94.7	86.8	115.	-5.80	21.8	0.897	0.681	0.636	0.892	0.983	0.766
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	86.4	83.3	86.8	115.	-3.59	18.0	0.737	0.739	0.665	0.908	0.986	0.792
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	93.1	93.0	86.8	115.	-7.02	20.3	0.636	0.682	0.669	0.926	0.942	0.777
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	81.1	81.0	86.8	115.	-5.80	21.8	0.897	0.681	0.636	0.892	0.983	0.766
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	83.3	83.2	86.8	115.	-3.59	18.0	0.737	0.739	0.665	0.908	0.986	0.792
Mean-Princeton	[-]	79.9	79.8	86.8	115.	-7.02	20.3	0.636	0.682	0.669	0.926	0.942	0.777

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

91.0

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

85.5

80.9

89.2

124.

-8.34

21.6

0.826

0.688

0.645

0.901

0.983

0.772

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

80.9

76.0

89.2

124.

-13.2

22.1

0.666

0.646

0.665

0.920

0.969

0.773

CLM-Princeton

[-]

78.2

74.4

89.2

124.

-14.7

23.4

0.618

0.615

0.678

0.927

0.919

0.764

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

89.0

88.8

90.2

134.

-1.31

20.9

0.839

0.708

0.650

0.901

0.984

0.779

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

86.2

86.0

90.2

134.

-4.09

19.3

0.643

0.723

0.665

0.925

0.979

0.792

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

83.9

83.7

90.2

134.

-6.37

20.1

0.638

0.699

0.673

0.925

0.945

0.783

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

94.8

94.7

86.8

115.

-5.80

21.8

0.897

0.681

0.636

0.892

0.983

0.766

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

86.4

83.3

86.8

115.

-3.59

18.0

0.737

0.739

0.665

0.908

0.986

0.792

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

93.1

93.0

86.8

115.

-7.02

20.3

0.636

0.682

0.669

0.926

0.942

0.777

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

81.1

81.0

86.8

115.

-5.80

21.8

0.897

0.681

0.636

0.892

0.983

0.766

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

83.3

83.2

86.8

115.

-3.59

18.0

0.737

0.739

0.665

0.908

0.986

0.792

Mean-Princeton

[-]

79.9

79.8

86.8

115.

-7.02

20.3

0.636

0.682

0.669

0.926

0.942

0.777

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	88.7
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	75.3	75.0	87.3	161.	-12.3	21.1	0.948	0.627	0.624	0.890	0.957	0.745
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	70.5	70.5	87.3	161.	-16.7	22.6	0.882	0.567	0.651	0.897	0.951	0.743
CLM-Princeton	[-]	66.8	66.7	87.2	161.	-20.3	24.9	0.894	0.518	0.663	0.893	0.921	0.732
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	89.0	88.7	88.3	169.	0.525	20.2	1.00	0.645	0.638	0.882	0.908	0.742
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	87.0	86.9	88.3	169.	-1.22	18.9	0.916	0.667	0.651	0.893	0.910	0.754
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	83.0	82.8	88.1	169.	-5.28	19.7	0.982	0.652	0.652	0.881	0.865	0.740
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	69.4	69.0	84.9	138.	-13.4	21.6	0.981	0.597	0.620	0.885	0.989	0.742
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	79.2	78.9	84.9	138.	-6.00	17.5	0.922	0.682	0.644	0.888	0.992	0.770
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	69.2	68.8	84.9	138.	-15.0	20.8	0.929	0.586	0.658	0.885	0.989	0.755
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	71.9	71.5	84.9	138.	-13.4	21.6	0.981	0.597	0.620	0.885	0.989	0.742
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	79.2	78.9	84.9	138.	-6.00	17.5	0.922	0.682	0.644	0.888	0.992	0.770
Mean-Princeton	[-]	70.1	69.9	84.9	138.	-15.0	20.8	0.929	0.586	0.658	0.885	0.989	0.755

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

88.7

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

75.3

75.0

87.3

161.

-12.3

21.1

0.948

0.627

0.624

0.890

0.957

0.745

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

70.5

87.3

161.

-16.7

22.6

0.882

0.567

0.651

0.897

0.951

0.743

CLM-Princeton

[-]

66.8

66.7

87.2

161.

-20.3

24.9

0.894

0.518

0.663

0.893

0.921

0.732

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

89.0

88.7

88.3

169.

0.525

20.2

1.00

0.645

0.638

0.882

0.908

0.742

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

87.0

86.9

88.3

169.

-1.22

18.9

0.916

0.667

0.651

0.893

0.910

0.754

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

83.0

82.8

88.1

169.

-5.28

19.7

0.982

0.652

0.881

0.865

0.740

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

69.4

69.0

84.9

138.

-13.4

21.6

0.981

0.597

0.620

0.885

0.989

0.742

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

79.2

78.9

84.9

138.

-6.00

17.5

0.922

0.682

0.644

0.888

0.992

0.770

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

69.2

68.8

84.9

138.

-15.0

20.8

0.929

0.586

0.658

0.885

0.989

0.755

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

71.9

71.5

84.9

138.

-13.4

21.6

0.981

0.597

0.620

0.885

0.989

0.742

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

79.2

78.9

84.9

138.

-6.00

17.5

0.922

0.682

0.644

0.888

0.992

0.770

Mean-Princeton

[-]

70.1

69.9

84.9

138.

-15.0

20.8

0.929

0.586

0.658

0.885

0.989

0.755

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	74.8
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	63.3	63.4	74.5	125.	-10.9	20.7	0.586	0.760	0.744	0.949	0.985	0.836
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	63.8	63.7	74.5	125.	-10.6	19.0	0.384	0.760	0.773	0.969	0.974	0.850
CLM-Princeton	[-]	60.1	60.0	74.6	125.	-14.4	20.2	0.400	0.729	0.779	0.967	0.992	0.849
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	70.1	69.6	74.7	131.	-5.18	20.3	0.607	0.780	0.725	0.947	0.989	0.833
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	73.5	72.8	74.7	131.	-1.90	16.7	0.381	0.821	0.766	0.968	0.980	0.860
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	70.1	69.4	74.7	130.	-5.32	16.8	0.388	0.818	0.768	0.969	0.993	0.863
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	86.3	84.3	74.0	96.1	-10.3	20.6	0.570	0.742	0.753	0.949	0.971	0.834
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	74.0	72.9	74.0	96.1	-1.40	16.2	0.366	0.816	0.776	0.970	0.955	0.859
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	87.3	80.9	74.0	96.1	-7.64	17.4	0.442	0.793	0.775	0.963	0.992	0.860
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	64.1	63.8	74.0	96.1	-10.3	20.6	0.570	0.742	0.753	0.949	0.971	0.834
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	74.0	72.9	74.0	96.1	-1.40	16.2	0.366	0.816	0.776	0.970	0.955	0.859
Mean-Princeton	[-]	67.5	66.5	74.0	96.1	-7.64	17.4	0.442	0.793	0.775	0.963	0.992	0.860

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

74.8

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

63.3

63.4

74.5

125.

-10.9

20.7

0.586

0.760

0.744

0.949

0.985

0.836

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

63.8

63.7

74.5

125.

-10.6

19.0

0.384

0.760

0.773

0.969

0.974

0.850

CLM-Princeton

[-]

60.1

60.0

74.6

125.

-14.4

20.2

0.400

0.729

0.779

0.967

0.992

0.849

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

70.1

69.6

74.7

131.

-5.18

20.3

0.607

0.780

0.725

0.947

0.989

0.833

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

73.5

72.8

74.7

131.

-1.90

16.7

0.381

0.821

0.766

0.968

0.980

0.860

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

70.1

69.4

74.7

130.

-5.32

16.8

0.388

0.818

0.768

0.969

0.993

0.863

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

86.3

84.3

74.0

96.1

-10.3

20.6

0.570

0.742

0.753

0.949

0.971

0.834

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

74.0

72.9

74.0

96.1

-1.40

16.2

0.366

0.816

0.776

0.970

0.955

0.859

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

87.3

80.9

74.0

96.1

-7.64

17.4

0.442

0.793

0.775

0.963

0.992

0.860

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

64.1

63.8

74.0

96.1

-10.3

20.6

0.570

0.742

0.753

0.949

0.971

0.834

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

74.0

72.9

74.0

96.1

-1.40

16.2

0.366

0.816

0.776

0.970

0.955

0.859

Mean-Princeton

[-]

67.5

66.5

74.0

96.1

-7.64

17.4

0.442

0.793

0.775

0.963

0.992

0.860

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	67.8
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	87.2	89.0	69.6	57.9	19.0	28.7	0.836	0.555	0.599	0.884	0.987	0.725
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	73.7	74.8	69.6	57.9	4.70	20.9	0.821	0.684	0.627	0.866	0.949	0.751
CLM-Princeton	[-]	73.4	74.8	69.3	57.7	5.21	19.4	0.806	0.704	0.645	0.878	0.992	0.773
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	83.6	88.4	67.9	59.4	20.7	28.9	0.840	0.578	0.628	0.885	0.981	0.740
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	68.8	75.4	67.9	59.4	7.58	21.9	0.716	0.700	0.649	0.886	0.929	0.763
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	69.9	75.0	67.7	59.1	7.34	20.3	0.510	0.721	0.659	0.932	0.986	0.792
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	118.	121.	70.0	63.6	20.3	29.9	1.17	0.525	0.544	0.827	0.982	0.684
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	76.5	79.0	70.0	63.6	8.77	21.5	1.04	0.596	0.594	0.833	0.974	0.718
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	99.3	106.	70.0	63.6	10.9	21.8	0.927	0.606	0.586	0.853	0.980	0.722
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	88.9	90.5	70.0	63.6	20.3	29.9	1.17	0.525	0.544	0.827	0.982	0.684
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	76.5	79.0	70.0	63.6	8.77	21.5	1.04	0.596	0.594	0.833	0.974	0.718
Mean-Princeton	[-]	79.7	81.0	70.0	63.6	10.9	21.8	0.927	0.606	0.586	0.853	0.980	0.722

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

67.8

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

87.2

89.0

69.6

57.9

19.0

28.7

0.836

0.555

0.599

0.884

0.987

0.725

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

73.7

74.8

69.6

57.9

4.70

20.9

0.821

0.684

0.627

0.866

0.949

0.751

CLM-Princeton

[-]

73.4

74.8

69.3

57.7

5.21

19.4

0.806

0.704

0.645

0.878

0.992

0.773

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

83.6

88.4

67.9

59.4

20.7

28.9

0.840

0.578

0.628

0.885

0.981

0.740

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

68.8

75.4

67.9

59.4

7.58

21.9

0.716

0.700

0.649

0.886

0.929

0.763

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

69.9

75.0

67.7

59.1

7.34

20.3

0.510

0.721

0.659

0.932

0.986

0.792

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

118.

121.

70.0

63.6

20.3

29.9

1.17

0.525

0.544

0.827

0.982

0.684

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

76.5

79.0

70.0

63.6

8.77

21.5

1.04

0.596

0.594

0.833

0.974

0.718

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

99.3

106.

70.0

63.6

10.9

21.8

0.927

0.606

0.586

0.853

0.980

0.722

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

88.9

90.5

70.0

63.6

20.3

29.9

1.17

0.525

0.544

0.827

0.982

0.684

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

76.5

79.0

70.0

63.6

8.77

21.5

1.04

0.596

0.594

0.833

0.974

0.718

Mean-Princeton

[-]

79.7

81.0

70.0

63.6

10.9

21.8

0.927

0.606

0.586

0.853

0.980

0.722

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	77.5
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	80.6	80.6	77.7	71.8	2.94	19.0	0.534	0.820	0.756	0.953	0.993	0.856
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	69.3	69.1	77.7	71.8	-8.66	18.6	0.418	0.807	0.765	0.964	0.994	0.859
CLM-Princeton	[-]	68.4	68.4	77.6	71.5	-9.23	17.1	0.329	0.809	0.792	0.971	0.995	0.872
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	85.8	85.8	77.5	67.2	8.35	19.9	0.578	0.807	0.760	0.951	0.992	0.854
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	75.0	75.3	77.5	67.2	-2.13	17.0	0.444	0.861	0.763	0.962	0.989	0.868
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	73.9	74.4	77.5	67.1	-2.98	15.2	0.285	0.863	0.788	0.976	0.996	0.882
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	104.	103.	77.4	78.0	6.13	19.6	0.642	0.818	0.748	0.946	0.992	0.851
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	75.3	75.6	77.4	78.0	-1.89	16.8	0.473	0.861	0.757	0.960	0.988	0.865
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	83.8	83.3	77.4	78.0	-1.71	15.4	0.382	0.877	0.772	0.967	0.995	0.877
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	83.5	83.6	77.4	78.0	6.13	19.6	0.642	0.818	0.748	0.946	0.992	0.851
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	75.3	75.6	77.4	78.0	-1.89	16.8	0.473	0.861	0.757	0.960	0.988	0.865
Mean-Princeton	[-]	75.4	75.7	77.4	78.0	-1.71	15.4	0.382	0.877	0.772	0.967	0.995	0.877

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

77.5

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

80.6

77.7

71.8

2.94

19.0

0.534

0.820

0.756

0.953

0.993

0.856

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

69.3

69.1

77.7

71.8

-8.66

18.6

0.418

0.807

0.765

0.964

0.994

0.859

CLM-Princeton

[-]

68.4

77.6

71.5

-9.23

17.1

0.329

0.809

0.792

0.971

0.995

0.872

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

85.8

77.5

67.2

8.35

19.9

0.578

0.807

0.760

0.951

0.992

0.854

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

75.0

75.3

77.5

67.2

-2.13

17.0

0.444

0.861

0.763

0.962

0.989

0.868

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

73.9

74.4

77.5

67.1

-2.98

15.2

0.285

0.863

0.788

0.976

0.996

0.882

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

104.

103.

77.4

78.0

6.13

19.6

0.642

0.818

0.748

0.946

0.992

0.851

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

75.3

75.6

77.4

78.0

-1.89

16.8

0.473

0.861

0.757

0.960

0.988

0.865

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

83.8

83.3

77.4

78.0

-1.71

15.4

0.382

0.877

0.772

0.967

0.995

0.877

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

83.5

83.6

77.4

78.0

6.13

19.6

0.642

0.818

0.748

0.946

0.992

0.851

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

75.3

75.6

77.4

78.0

-1.89

16.8

0.473

0.861

0.757

0.960

0.988

0.865

Mean-Princeton

[-]

75.4

75.7

77.4

78.0

-1.71

15.4

0.382

0.877

0.772

0.967

0.995

0.877

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	138.
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	137.	137.	137.	146.	-0.735	19.3	1.54	0.569	0.397	0.768	0.901	0.607
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	122.	122.	137.	146.	-14.8	22.8	1.19	0.365	0.416	0.821	0.984	0.601
CLM-Princeton	[-]	116.	115.	137.	146.	-21.6	26.0	0.961	0.276	0.492	0.870	0.850	0.596
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	140.	140.	137.	154.	2.26	19.3	1.49	0.562	0.406	0.780	0.948	0.620
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	129.	128.	137.	154.	-8.84	20.3	1.22	0.448	0.423	0.817	0.996	0.621
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	121.	121.	137.	155.	-16.0	22.4	1.05	0.363	0.488	0.854	0.971	0.633
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	139.	140.	137.	141.	2.42	18.2	1.81	0.593	0.392	0.719	0.871	0.593
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	128.	129.	137.	141.	-8.08	17.7	1.24	0.500	0.425	0.814	0.937	0.620
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	120.	120.	137.	141.	-16.2	21.9	0.910	0.332	0.470	0.874	0.713	0.572
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	139.	139.	137.	141.	2.42	18.2	1.81	0.593	0.392	0.719	0.871	0.593
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	128.	129.	137.	141.	-8.08	17.7	1.24	0.500	0.425	0.814	0.937	0.620
Mean-Princeton	[-]	120.	121.	137.	141.	-16.2	21.9	0.910	0.332	0.470	0.874	0.713	0.572

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

138.

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

137.

146.

-0.735

19.3

1.54

0.569

0.397

0.768

0.901

0.607

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

122.

137.

146.

-14.8

22.8

1.19

0.365

0.416

0.821

0.984

0.601

CLM-Princeton

[-]

116.

115.

137.

146.

-21.6

26.0

0.961

0.276

0.492

0.870

0.850

0.596

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

140.

137.

154.

2.26

19.3

1.49

0.562

0.406

0.780

0.948

0.620

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

129.

128.

137.

154.

-8.84

20.3

1.22

0.448

0.423

0.817

0.996

0.621

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

121.

137.

155.

-16.0

22.4

1.05

0.363

0.488

0.854

0.971

0.633

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

139.

140.

137.

141.

2.42

18.2

1.81

0.593

0.392

0.719

0.871

0.593

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

128.

129.

137.

141.

-8.08

17.7

1.24

0.500

0.425

0.814

0.937

0.620

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

120.

137.

141.

-16.2

21.9

0.910

0.332

0.470

0.874

0.713

0.572

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

139.

137.

141.

2.42

18.2

1.81

0.593

0.392

0.719

0.871

0.593

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

128.

129.

137.

141.

-8.08

17.7

1.24

0.500

0.425

0.814

0.937

0.620

Mean-Princeton

[-]

120.

121.

137.

141.

-16.2

21.9

0.910

0.332

0.470

0.874

0.713

0.572

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	137.
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	121.	121.	136.	159.	-14.2	24.1	1.45	0.508	0.491	0.797	0.996	0.657
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	114.	114.	136.	159.	-21.6	27.0	1.16	0.403	0.523	0.840	0.997	0.657
CLM-Princeton	[-]	112.	112.	135.	158.	-23.4	27.6	1.01	0.373	0.554	0.863	0.982	0.665
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	129.	129.	136.	162.	-7.16	21.2	1.34	0.584	0.498	0.819	0.967	0.673
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	124.	125.	136.	162.	-11.4	20.5	0.965	0.555	0.530	0.870	0.998	0.697
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	121.	122.	136.	162.	-14.1	21.4	0.969	0.516	0.550	0.869	0.976	0.692
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	123.	122.	134.	150.	-12.4	24.1	1.61	0.522	0.456	0.774	0.996	0.641
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	125.	124.	134.	150.	-9.69	18.9	1.40	0.592	0.520	0.795	0.995	0.685
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	123.	122.	134.	150.	-14.7	20.7	0.963	0.508	0.548	0.871	0.915	0.678
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	122.	122.	134.	150.	-12.4	24.1	1.61	0.522	0.456	0.774	0.996	0.641
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	125.	124.	134.	150.	-9.69	18.9	1.40	0.592	0.520	0.795	0.995	0.685
Mean-Princeton	[-]	120.	119.	134.	150.	-14.7	20.7	0.963	0.508	0.548	0.871	0.915	0.678

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

137.

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

121.

136.

159.

-14.2

24.1

1.45

0.508

0.491

0.797

0.996

0.657

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

114.

136.

159.

-21.6

27.0

1.16

0.403

0.523

0.840

0.997

0.657

CLM-Princeton

[-]

112.

135.

158.

-23.4

27.6

1.01

0.373

0.554

0.863

0.982

0.665

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

129.

136.

162.

-7.16

21.2

1.34

0.584

0.498

0.819

0.967

0.673

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

124.

125.

136.

162.

-11.4

20.5

0.965

0.555

0.530

0.870

0.998

0.697

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

121.

122.

136.

162.

-14.1

21.4

0.969

0.516

0.550

0.869

0.976

0.692

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

123.

122.

134.

150.

-12.4

24.1

1.61

0.522

0.456

0.774

0.996

0.641

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

125.

124.

134.

150.

-9.69

18.9

1.40

0.592

0.520

0.795

0.995

0.685

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

123.

122.

134.

150.

-14.7

20.7

0.963

0.508

0.548

0.871

0.915

0.678

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

122.

134.

150.

-12.4

24.1

1.61

0.522

0.456

0.774

0.996

0.641

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

125.

124.

134.

150.

-9.69

18.9

1.40

0.592

0.520

0.795

0.995

0.685

Mean-Princeton

[-]

120.

119.

134.

150.

-14.7

20.7

0.963

0.508

0.548

0.871

0.915

0.678

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	23.1
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	19.4	19.9	23.2	10.9	-3.27	20.1	0.287	0.812	0.718	0.979	0.840	0.813
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	36.7	22.5	23.2	10.9	-0.801	19.0	0.167	0.842	0.714	0.987	0.933	0.838
CLM-Princeton	[-]	38.2	29.6	23.5	11.5	6.03	22.2	0.221	0.814	0.680	0.984	0.951	0.822
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	24.4	24.5	23.1	6.53	1.49	19.5	0.308	0.800	0.733	0.978	0.844	0.818
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	27.2	27.1	23.1	6.53	4.08	19.5	0.199	0.823	0.717	0.985	0.917	0.832
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	31.8	31.9	23.3	7.11	8.66	23.1	0.316	0.793	0.677	0.978	0.958	0.817
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	15.3	15.2	24.2	11.5	1.99	23.3	0.306	0.766	0.693	0.978	0.782	0.782
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	35.2	29.6	24.2	11.5	5.39	20.3	0.154	0.810	0.710	0.988	0.897	0.823
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	27.3	27.3	24.2	11.5	12.3	27.2	0.290	0.744	0.644	0.979	0.944	0.791
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	26.4	26.2	24.2	11.5	1.99	23.3	0.306	0.766	0.693	0.978	0.782	0.782
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	29.9	29.6	24.2	11.5	5.39	20.3	0.154	0.810	0.710	0.988	0.897	0.823
Mean-Princeton	[-]	36.7	36.5	24.2	11.5	12.3	27.2	0.290	0.744	0.644	0.979	0.944	0.791

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

23.1

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

19.4

19.9

23.2

10.9

-3.27

20.1

0.287

0.812

0.718

0.979

0.840

0.813

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

36.7

22.5

23.2

10.9

-0.801

19.0

0.167

0.842

0.714

0.987

0.933

0.838

CLM-Princeton

[-]

38.2

29.6

23.5

11.5

6.03

22.2

0.221

0.814

0.680

0.984

0.951

0.822

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

24.4

24.5

23.1

6.53

1.49

19.5

0.308

0.800

0.733

0.978

0.844

0.818

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

27.2

27.1

23.1

6.53

4.08

19.5

0.199

0.823

0.717

0.985

0.917

0.832

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

31.8

31.9

23.3

7.11

8.66

23.1

0.316

0.793

0.677

0.978

0.958

0.817

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

15.3

15.2

24.2

11.5

1.99

23.3

0.306

0.766

0.693

0.978

0.782

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

35.2

29.6

24.2

11.5

5.39

20.3

0.154

0.810

0.710

0.988

0.897

0.823

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

27.3

24.2

11.5

12.3

27.2

0.290

0.744

0.644

0.979

0.944

0.791

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

26.4

26.2

24.2

11.5

1.99

23.3

0.306

0.766

0.693

0.978

0.782

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

29.9

29.6

24.2

11.5

5.39

20.3

0.154

0.810

0.710

0.988

0.897

0.823

Mean-Princeton

[-]

36.7

36.5

24.2

11.5

12.3

27.2

0.290

0.744

0.644

0.979

0.944

0.791

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]	Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	82.5
CLM-CRUJRA	[-]	74.4	74.2	82.1	105.	-7.99	19.6	0.447	0.808	0.761	0.962	0.992	0.857
CLM-GSWP3	[-]	71.7	71.3	82.1	105.	-10.9	19.6	0.411	0.793	0.767	0.965	0.995	0.857
CLM-Princeton	[-]	68.7	68.5	82.0	105.	-13.6	20.3	0.364	0.766	0.776	0.969	0.987	0.855
ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA	[-]	82.7	82.1	82.4	104.	-0.343	18.9	0.576	0.824	0.758	0.950	0.988	0.856
ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3	[-]	80.9	79.9	82.4	104.	-2.58	17.1	0.444	0.855	0.766	0.962	0.989	0.868
ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton	[-]	78.1	77.2	82.4	104.	-5.14	16.4	0.383	0.851	0.781	0.966	0.996	0.875
JSBACH-CRUJRA	[-]	91.7	93.6	81.3	97.1	-2.31	19.5	0.623	0.804	0.755	0.945	0.980	0.848
JSBACH-GSWP3	[-]	81.9	81.6	81.3	97.1	0.383	16.6	0.458	0.860	0.765	0.961	0.995	0.869
JSBACH-Princeton	[-]	86.5	89.2	81.3	97.1	-3.03	17.0	0.436	0.849	0.770	0.961	0.981	0.866
Mean-CRUJRA	[-]	79.3	78.9	81.3	97.1	-2.31	19.5	0.623	0.804	0.755	0.945	0.980	0.848
Mean-GSWP3	[-]	81.9	81.6	81.3	97.1	0.383	16.6	0.458	0.860	0.765	0.961	0.995	0.869
Mean-Princeton	[-]	78.6	78.2	81.3	97.1	-3.03	17.0	0.436	0.849	0.770	0.961	0.981	0.866

Download Data

Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]

Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]

Bias [W m-2]

RMSE [W m-2]

Phase Shift [months]

Bias Score [1]

RMSE Score [1]

Seasonal Cycle Score [1]

Spatial Distribution Score [1]

Overall Score [1]

Benchmark

[-]

82.5

CLM-CRUJRA

[-]

74.4

74.2

82.1

105.

-7.99

19.6

0.447

0.808

0.761

0.962

0.992

0.857

CLM-GSWP3

[-]

71.7

71.3

82.1

105.

-10.9

19.6

0.411

0.793

0.767

0.965

0.995

0.857

CLM-Princeton

[-]

68.7

68.5

82.0

105.

-13.6

20.3

0.364

0.766

0.776

0.969

0.987

0.855

ISBA-CTRIP-CRUJRA

[-]

82.7

82.1

82.4

104.

-0.343

18.9

0.576

0.824

0.758

0.950

0.988

0.856

ISBA-CTRIP-GSWP3

[-]

80.9

79.9

82.4

104.

-2.58

17.1

0.444

0.855

0.766

0.962

0.989

0.868

ISBA-CTRIP-Princeton

[-]

78.1

77.2

82.4

104.

-5.14

16.4

0.383

0.851

0.781

0.966

0.996

0.875

JSBACH-CRUJRA

[-]

91.7

93.6

81.3

97.1

-2.31

19.5

0.623

0.804

0.755

0.945

0.980

0.848

JSBACH-GSWP3

[-]

81.9

81.6

81.3

97.1

0.383

16.6

0.458

0.860

0.765

0.961

0.995

0.869

JSBACH-Princeton

[-]

86.5

89.2

81.3

97.1

-3.03

17.0

0.436

0.849

0.770

0.961

0.981

0.866

Mean-CRUJRA

[-]

79.3

78.9

81.3

97.1

-2.31

19.5

0.623

0.804

0.755

0.945

0.980

0.848

Mean-GSWP3

[-]

81.9

81.6

81.3

97.1

0.383

16.6

0.458

0.860

0.765

0.961

0.995

0.869

Mean-Princeton

[-]

78.6

78.2

81.3

97.1

-3.03

17.0

0.436

0.849

0.770

0.961

0.981

0.866

Temporally integrated period mean click to collapse contents

BENCHMARK MEAN Data not available

MODEL MEAN Data not available

BIAS

BIAS SCORE Data not available

RMSE

RMSE SCORE Data not available

BENCHMARK MAX MONTH Data not available

MODEL MAX MONTH Data not available

DIFFERENCE IN MAX MONTH Data not available

SEASONAL CYCLE SCORE Data not available

SPATIAL TAYLOR DIAGRAM Data not available

MODEL COLORS Data not available

Spatially integrated regional mean click to collapse contents

MODEL COLORS Data not available

REGIONAL MEAN Data not available

ANNUAL CYCLE Data not available

MONTHLY ANOMALY Data not available

ANNUAL CYCLE Data not available

Data Information

Mean State
All Models
Data Information

Title:: CERES EBAF TOA and Surface Fluxes

Version:: Ed4.1

Institutions:: NASA Langley Research Center

Source:: Monthly mean surface fluxes calculated by a radiative transfer model and constrained by the combined Terra and Aqua SSF1deg measurements

History:: 2019-06-25: downloaded source from https://ceres.larc.nasa.gov/products-info.php?product=EBAF; 2019-08-13: converted to netCDF with https://github.com/mmu2019/Datasets/blob/master/read-rns-ceres.py

References:: Loeb, N.G., D.R. Doelling, H. Wang, W. Su, C. Nguyen, J.G. Corbett, L. Liang, C. Mitrescu, F.G. Rose, and S. Kato (2018), Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) Top-of-Atmosphere (TOA) Edition-4.0 Data Product, Journal of Climate, 31(2), 895-918, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0208.1; Kato, S., F. G. Rose, D. A. Rutan, T. E. Thorsen, N. G. Loeb, D. R. Doelling, X. Huang, W. L. Smith, W. Su, and S.-H. Ham (2018), Surface irradiances of Edition 4.0 Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) data product, Journal of Climate, 31, 4501-4527, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0523.1

Comments:: time_period: 2000-01 through 2018-12; original_temporal_resolution: monthly; original_spatial_resolution: 1 degree; original_units: W m-2; final_temporal_resolution: monthly; final_spatial_resolution: 0.5 degree; final_units: W m-2

Convention:: CF-1.7

SurfaceNetRadiation / CERESed4.1 / 2000-2019 / global / CLM-CRUJRA

Temporally integrated period mean click to collapse contents

Spatially integrated regional mean click to collapse contents

SurfaceNetRadiation / CERESed4.1 / 2000-2019 / global / MNAME

Data Information

loading